St. Louis' Webzine for Kids
Text Only
January 2008 Vol. 9 Issue 1


Regular Features

St. Louis History
Things To Do
Fun & Games
Answers


News Stories

Joffrey Ballet
First Lego
First Books
Stock Market Game
McKissack 2
Tennis
Young Achiever

Math Mania
Math Mania answers

Books

All News Stories

Text Only


Contact Us

 

 

Last in 2-part series

Local author critiques kids' writing

Kids' author Pat McKissack of St. Louis had some good things to say about 11-year-old Haley Erstall's writing style. But, the prize-winning author also offered some "constructive criticism" to help Haley improve.


Haley Ernstall

Haley was one of the 5th graders at Independence Elementary School who read their original stories to Ms McKissack last month. They had the conversations via a videoconference session.

In November, kids in teacher Michele Kelly's class listened while Ms. McKissack gave them some writing tips. She came back in December to critique the stories they wrote after the first session. (To read the first article, click here.)

(To read full texts of three of the kids' stories, click here.)

Ms. McKissack regularly shares writing advice with area kids through videoconferences sponsored by the Cooperating School Districts (CSD). She is in a CSD studio and the kids are in their regular classrooms.

Haley's school is in Weldon Springs. She lives in St. Charles. Her story, entitled "Champion," was about a boy who helps his basketball team win a championship.

Ms. McKissack told Haley her writing included "good descriptions" and "good dialogue" between the characters in her story. "You write very well," she told Haley.

However, she urged her to work more on "transitions" between one part of the story and the others. "You need to help the reader go from one scene to the next," she said.

Ms. McKissack said transition sometimes can be accomplished with a couple words, such as "next morning," Other times it might need a sentence or two, she added.

The author told the kids that even established writers such as herself need to have people around them who can offer advice that make their writing better. "We're always trying to get better," she told the kids. Haley said she's done quite a bit of other writing, including biographies of her sister, 7-year-old Maggie and her dog, Pepper.

Haley said she described Maggie, who is a Down's Syndrome child, as "being more than my sister; she's my friend."


Kaitlyn Howard

Eleven-year-old Kaitlyn Howard was another student who read her story to Ms. McKissack. Her story was titled, "Ryan's Only Wish."

It told of a boy who was in the hospital with cancer and whose dad was serving in the military. Ryan's only wish was that his dad could be home with him for Christmas.

Ms.McKissack told Kaitlyn, "You built the drama well and developed your characters well. Ryan was very likeable. And your transitions between scenes were good. And I liked the surprise at the end."

In the story, Ryan's dad is sitting on the couch in their home when Ryan comes home.

Ms. McKissack said her story would have even more impact if she showed the emotions that the characters were feeling. "Rather than just telling someone is sad, try to use words that show the emotion," she told Kaitlyn.

Kaitlyn thought the "constructive criticism" would help her writing.

The kids get a chance to rewrite their stories. Then, Ms. Kelly will send both the original and the rewrite to Ms. McKissack. The author promised the kids to mark all the stories and return them.


Alexis Liker

Ten-year-old Alexis Liker of St. Charles read her story, "The Lonely Caterpillar." It might have been the shortest of the stories critiqued by Ms. McKissack.

But, she told Alexis, "That's a beautiful story." She said she was intrigued as Alexis mixed facts with fictional elements. They gave the caterpillar human characteristics.

The story tells about a caterpillar that knows he's ugly and doesn't have any friends.

But, the story has a happy ending because the caterpillar is transformed into a beautiful butterfly that can fly around the find new friends. The story is illustrated by Alexis' own colorful drawing of the butterfly.

Alexis said she got the idea for the butterfly story from a piece she had written earlier. That was the story of the metamorphosis of a maggot into a fly. She admitted that transformation didn't have the same appeal.

"I like the caterpillar-to-butterfly idea better," she said.

Alexis said her best type writing is poetry. "I read the poetry my dad wrote when he was a kid," she said.

But, she doesn't plan to be a writer when she grows up. "I want to be an animal trainer, of either tigers or dolphins," she said.

McKissack sidebar

Texts of three original stories

(Editor's note: These are three original stories by 5th graders at Independence Elementary School that were critiqued by St. Louis kids' author Pat McKissack. Young Saint Louis.com covered the videoconferences between Ms. McKissack and the kids in their creative writing course. To read the main story, click here.)

Story No. 1:

"Champion"
By Haley Ernstall

"He's dribbling down the court…he shoots…five seconds the time…the crowd is cheering and then 'Ohh.' It bounces off the rim. Well, that's the end of it, folks," sighs the announcer.

Kyle walked over to the benches, where his parents were.

"Great job, Kyle. You did great," said his parents. "That's not what everyone else thinks," drooped Kyle. He started to walk away when his team bumped him and said, "Nice going, Kyle."

He sighed, "I'm never going to make it to the championship."

On the way home, Kyle fell asleep because he was in Chicago and he lives in Arizona. In Kyle's dream, he could see a basketball player practicing. "Oh, My Gosh, that's Shaquille O'Neal," he gasped.

"I heard you lost your game today. When I get frustrated and think I can't do it, I just never stop practicing. So, you should practice at least once a day if you really want to turn out to be the greatest player you always dreamed of being," he advised.

Kyle jumped up and was wide-awake. "Did you have a good nap," laughed his dad. "We're about halfway there. Just a few more hours."

Kyle looked out the window. They were in Colorado. The rest of the way there, all Kyle thought about was his dream. Finally, they reached 56th Street where his house was.

He ran inside where his dog, Sammy, was. Kyle loved Sammy. He was basically his only friend. It was getting late, so Kyle and Sammy went to bed.

The next morning, Kyle had another game. He had practiced ever since he got home and again in the morning before his game. On the way to the game, Kyle was thinking about his dream again and how he could be the best player.

They finally reached the gym. The game was about to begin. Kyle played in the 1st quarter. He did OK but he could have done better. In the 2nd and 3rd quarters, he was on the bench.

Finally, he was in the 4th quarter. There was 10 seconds left. The other team has the ball. Kyle's team just needs three more points. They passed the ball to Kyle. Kyle got the ball and ran.

He was almost there. Everyone kept yelling for him "Slow Down." He was at the 3-point line and there was someone almost on him. He shot, but he closed his eyes.

It was very quiet and three seconds were left. He still had his eyes shut. He heard the timer go off but the crowd hesitated, then cheered.

Kyle opened his eyes. He had won the game to the championship. His team ran over, lifted him up and started to shout, "Kyle, Kyle."

-The end-

Story No. 2:

Ryan's Only Wish
By Kaitlyn Howard

It was around 12:37 a.m. and Ryan was still in the hospital. He was used to the hospital beds but not quite used to their clothes. He was sick of not being able to see his friends even though his only friend was his Teddy Bear.

He had spent 2˝ years in the hospital. He was five years old when he started having cancer and he'd been only home one time. He missed not being able to swim or play two-hand touch football!!

"Mommy, I can't go to sleep," Ryan said. It was almost Christmas and Ryan has been wishing he could be home for Christmas. "Mom, will I be home in time for Christmas?" Ryan said. "I don't know, Honey. This is one of those things you never find out," his mother whispered.

Ryan is about 4-foot-2 and is bald due to all the chemo. The hospital room he stays in has a huge window and ever night he looks for a shooting star. So far, he's only seen two. He is always thinking about others and is used to all of it. He has a new bruise starting on this leg. As he noticed it, he told his mom. "Mommy," he whispered.

Yes, Honey."

"I kind of have a new bruise starting."

"Are you all right, Honey?"

His mom immediately calls the emergency room and they were up right away. His mom was a tall, skinny woman with long brown hair and is always worrying about Ryan. Ryan's dad is in the military and rarely sees Ryan. The main reason Ryan wants to be home for Christmas is to see his loving father.

Days pass and Ryan decided to write a letter to his father so he got out a piece of paper and a pen and wrote:

Dear Daddy.
When will you be home? I really miss you. Please write me back.
                                                          Love, Ryan Settle

A week passed and no response. Ryan was sitting in the cafeteria when a mailman walked up to him and said, "Are you Ryan Settle?"

"Yes I am Ryan Settle. Do you have a letter for me," asked Ryan.

"Indeed I do," replied the mailman.

"Thank you," Ryan shouted with glee.

The letter was from Michael Settle and said:

Dear Son,
I miss you and I don't think I'll be back for Christmas unless a miracle happens. So be good.
                                                         With love, Daddy

Ryan was upset and very sad although he understood. He thought to himself, miracles can happen. You just have to believe?

Days before Christmas, a doctor as usual came to check on Ryan. Everything was fine for the first time and the doctor said, "Ryan, you might be able to go home for Christmas."

"For real," Ryan shouted down the hospital hall.

"What's wrong, Honey?" his mom yelled as she was running to him.

"Nothing. I am absolutely fine, really I am."

"Okay, then what did you want to tell me."

"The doctor said I could go home for Christmas," Ryan said in a joyful voice.

"Is that true?" his mom questioned him.

"Yes, Mom. It is," explained Ryan.

Ryan and his mom were flipping through the channels when they saw the headline: "The Chinese take a break." Ryan and his mother stayed on this channel and it said the Chinese and Americans have stopped the fighting.

Ryan and his mom both stopped and looked at each other for a moment. The next day at nine sharp, Ryan and his mom returned to their house for the first time in a while. He was surprised to see a Christmas tree with presents piled high.

Also Ryan's father was sitting on the couch. "Daddy, Daddy," Ryan shouted with joy. "How come you are home?"

His dad said that since the Chinese were done fighting they were allowed to come home.

"I told you myself miracles do happen and I was right. So, since it's Christmas, do you want to open presents."

There were wonderful gifts piled him behind him. Ryan opened all sorts of gifts such as remote-controlled cars, footballs, basketballs, shirts and pants. The best gift of all was given last.

Ryan was opening a gift with doggy wrapping paper when a wet little nose popped out. It was a longhaired miniature Dachshund. Ryan was very excited and immediately had a name for her.

"I will name her Ginger." And from that point on Ryan and Ginger were the best of friends.

-The End-

Story No. 3:

The Lonely Caterpillar
By Alexis Liker

One day, a caterpillar named Kali was squirming along. She was lonely. She wanted to play with her friends. But, all of them were big blue butterflies. She felt left out because she couldn't fly.

She never would become a butterfly, she thought. So she asked Mr. Ant if she would ever become a butterfly. But, he said, "No," and went out for some food.

Kali was even more lonely so she took a nap. When she woke up, she was in a dark, shiny thing. "What is this?" she exclaimed. "This is new to me. Am I turning into a butterfly?"

Then, she heard something crack. The dark slimy thing opened. She hopped out and she started to fly!

She had the most beautiful wings of all her friends. She flew out and went to show her friends. They were so amazed. So they played fly tag and Kali the butterfly never felt left out again.

-The End-

 

 


home : kid's stuff : fun & games : past stories : resources
contact us : for adults : bookstore

 

All pages ©2005, 2006 Young Saint Louis.com

 

 

website maintained by Blue's ArtHouse Graphics & Web Design